The Green Transition: Keeping it local
Weekly analysis of the shift towards a new economy.
Dear Reader,
Welcome to this week’s edition of the Green Transition from the Spotlight on Policy team.
The government is currently scrambling to secure the future of the British Steel site at Scunthorpe. Reports have suggested that its blast furnaces could be switched off within days, since the site’s owners, Jingye, have failed to order the raw materials needed to keep them going. One option currently being explored by government (and called for by Nigel Farage and Reform UK) is for the plant to be nationalised. Another is that the UK government should order the materials itself to keep the furnaces online. These negotiations come amid a turbulent international moment and just days after Keir Starmer declared the “end of globalisation”.
I visited Scunthorpe in January for the New Statesman, and found a town suffering through decline. Scunthorpe was founded for its steelworks, and still depends on them today. The UK has been here before. Last year, Tata Steel closed the blast furnaces at its plant in Port Talbot, south Wales. A year of negotiations between the government and Tata resulted in a £500m deal for the Indian multinational to oversee the construction of an electric arc furnace at the site – though 2,500 jobs were lost.
The government has an opportunity to learn from the mistakes that have been made in Wales. But to do so, it must act fast.
You can read my analysis of what could happen at Scunthorpe here.
Meanwhile, we have a great piece this week from Climate Emergency UK and Wildlife and Countryside Link. The two organisations are calling for a statutory duty for councils over climate and nature action, making it more straightforward for local authorities to take action on these twin crises.
Let’s get to it.
A quick note from the Green Transition team: from April 2025, this newsletter will become a weekly subscriber-only service. If you'd like to continue to receive your weekly updates on the politics and policy behind the move to a new, sustainable economy, we invite you to subscribe to the New Statesman using our exclusive introductory offer for new subscribers – just £12 (normally £120) for your first year*.
Keeping it local
By Isaac Beevor and Richard Benwell
Local government is finally in the spotlight in parliament; but regardless, councils may still feel ill at ease. With the Planning & Infrastructure Bill in its committee stage and the English Devolution Bill on the way, the Government is attempting the biggest overhaul of English councils since 1972. Unfortunately, both measures come nowhere near the action needed to tackle the twin climate and nature emergency.
On climate, the Government is taking positive action on renewable energy, but missing a huge range of other steps needed to decarbonise our economy. On nature, it is flogging the false narrative of nature as a blocker to development and pushing planning reforms that would weaken fundamental environmental protections.
Already, there is a risk the Government may fail to meet its legal obligations for carbon emissions reduction and nature recovery. These new reforms risk worsening environmental delivery at a local authority level. This would exacerbate the current failings, where weak and vague environmental duties for councils are often pushed aside by “harder” rules relating to development.
To ensure that planning reforms make a positive environmental contribution, the Government should introduce a statutory climate and nature duty for local authorities. The duty should be linked to specific targets under the Climate Change Act 2008 and the Environment Act 2021 to give more clarity to councils. This would enable transparent benchmarks to track progress, improving reporting on climate and nature action.
This lack of strong duties is surprising considering the last Labour government clearly thought councils were key to climate success. The rationale underpinning three climate indicators introduced in 2008 was that “action by local authorities is likely to be critical to the achievement of Government’s climate change objectives”. What has changed in the past 17 years? Are councils not crucial partners in 2025? Are the climate and ecological crises any less real almost two decades on?
The Climate Change Committee has recognised that councils are critical. It noted that “local authorities have powers or influence over roughly a third of emissions in their local areas.” The CCC criticised the broken link between national ambition and council action, saying environmental action is “hindered by a lack of clarity on who should be doing what, limited resources, competing priorities, and a fragmented, short-term funding landscape.” A 2024 Local Government Association survey backed this up as, “67 per cent of councils were very or fairly unconfident” they would achieve their net zero target.
A statutory duty would empower English councils to get the country back on track to meet climate targets and halt wildlife losses. The benefit of a clear statutory duty is obvious. The leading UK authority on climate action has been the Greater London Authority, which has had a duty to act on climate since day one. The GLA can certainly go further and faster, but it is no surprise that climate action has remained a core component of its work, even when mayoral and national governments priorities wavered.
The government has begun to recognise the need to divvy up national targets to delivery partners too. The Health and Care Act 2022 placed new duties on the NHS to consider statutory emissions and environmental targets. Updated statutory duties for the Crown Estate and Ofwat to consider nature and climate targets have recently been introduced. While councils do have general nature duties, these are too weak and vague to drive change. 48 per cent of local authorities have no relevant biodiversity policies or objectives in place, and only a quarter of authorities met their legal duty to consider what action they should take.
This is backed up by recent research from The Woodland Trust and Climate Emergency UK that only 27 per cent of local authorities have declared a nature emergency, compared to the almost 90 per cent that have declared climate emergencies.
Whilst the climate emergency has been more widely recognised with ambitious net zero targets, the CCC notes that “delivery… is currently inconsistent.” This is demonstrated in the Council Climate Action Scorecards. Councils scored 32 per cent on average, with 52 councils scoring 20 per cent or lower. Of the 52 councils that score 20 per cent or below, 49 are English and Northern Irish councils, nations that have no statutory duty for councils to act on climate.
With specific climate and nature responsibilities codified in law, councils would be more likely to prioritise environmental action in planning and allocate necessary resources. It would make addressing the climate and nature crises a legal requirement rather than simply a voluntary commitment. Of course, the Government would be setting councils up to fail if duties were not followed up with the appropriate guidance, resources and crucially, funding for local authorities.
Councils have begun calling for a climate statutory duty themselves. The Local Government Association’s Local Infrastructure & Net Zero Board voted to endorse the principle of a climate statutory duty, joining the District Council Network, London Councils, and ADEPT who have called for a statutory duty on climate change since 2022.
The Government should use this renewed planning overhaul to make councils’ climate and nature responsibilities clearer and stronger. Done well, councils will become the vehicle for the rapid action we need to reduce emissions and restore nature in England.
Isaac Beevor is Partnerships Director at Climate Emergency UK. Richard Benwell is chief executive of Wildlife and Countryside Link.
*T&Cs: This offer is for a one-year digital subscription to newstatesman.com for £12 and is limited to new subscribers only. After your first year, you will continue to pay £79 every 12 months thereafter saving 34 per cent off our rate of £120. This offer will expire on 30 June 2025. For overseas rates, please select your country when you visit the offer page or call our customer service team on +44 (0) 808 284 9422. Lines are open 9am-5pm GMT Monday-Friday.
The Green Transition is produced by Spotlight, the New Statesman's online policy section and print supplement. Spotlight reports on policy for the people who shape it and the business leaders it affects. Explore our in-depth reporting and analysis here.
Thank you for reading.
Please send any news or comments to: megan.kenyon@newstatesman.co.uk